while he was a conservatory student at Point Park. The actor auditioned for and won a part as “Cadillac No. 2” in the Pittsburgh-filmed 1998 miniseries “The Temptations.”
A friend of his won the role of “No. 1” (“I guess he had all the solos”), so when another opportunity came his way — the national tour of “A Chorus Line” — he opted for the stage.
“And now in the show I sing a Cadillac song, and it’s one of the first songs you hear. … Twenty years later, it’s come back to me, so I think I was destined to tell this story, somehow.”
There are other full-circle connections for Mr. Cornelious, 42, who also is an investor in the show and in another highly anticipated Broadway musical of the season — “Hadestown,” which has its official opening April 17.
He has been with “Ain’t Too Proud” since the earliest readings two years ago and the three-city tour leading up to New York. The musical has given him the confidence to settle down. After years of bouncing between Broadway and tours and rentals, he recently bought his first home, a condo in Brooklyn.
The show also helped him at a time when he was at a low point after his father, Melvin Cornelious of McKeesport, died at age 78 in 2015.
“He loved Motown, and this was his favorite group,” Mr. Cornelious said.
He was deeply feeling the loss of his father while he was touring with “Kinky Boots,” a job he took after he had sworn he “would never tour again.” He was beginning to question his life in theater when “Ain’t Too
Proud” came along.
The Temptations reminded him of being a kid in the car with his father listening to the Motown groups such as The O’Jays and The Four Tops.
“When I got this show, I felt like everything I’ve ever wanted I got,” he said. “I feel like with my father’s death, from the heavens above, he gave me everything I needed by getting this show.”
“Ain’t Too Proud” has a starry group behind it, including original Temptation Otis Williams and longtime manager Shelly Berger. The creative team includes “Jersey Boys” director Des McAnuff and choreographer Sergio Trujillo, and a script by award-winning playwright and Detroit native Dominique Morisseau, penning her first libretto and making her Broadway debut.
During the Toronto run of the show, the producers hired a bus, and Ms. Morisseau led the cast on a tour of the Motor City’s musical hot spots, including the row house where Diana Ross grew up.
“She wanted us to know that this is how they lived and tried to give as much knowledge as she could, so we could truly understand her writing,” Mr. Cornelious said.
Throughout The Temptations many years of making music, there was much turnover through defections and tragedy, and that’s where Richard Street, the character played by Mr. Cornelious in the second act, comes in.
In the first act, as the band gets together and earns fame, the actor plays seven other characters: the “Gloria” soloist, the voice of a judge, a tailor, a TV interviewer, a drug dealer, a bus
driver and a delivery man.
In most cases, he is bringing bad news in a comical way. “I’m the [’Ain’t Too Proud’] funny man,” he said with pride. His encouraging father had always told him that comedy was his strong suit.
“I have two or three lines, and I have to sort of steal the scenes and make everybody laugh. Dominique and the director gave me these huge moments, but I have to make something out of them.”
So far, laughter has been his greatest reward.
In the second act, as Richard Street, “I slide on.” The character of troubled Temptation Paul Williams is seen as stumbling offstage, allowing Street (Mr. Cornelious) to make the smooth transition to take his place.
Mr. Cornelious spoke fondly about how his hometown prepared him for the life of a Broadway actor. He is eager to see the new Pittsburgh Playhouse at Point Park, a small college when he was a student.
“I’m in awe,” he said, of the university’s scope Downtown.
“I loved where I was in school; I loved growing up in Pittsburgh,” he said. “It’s what made me able to tackle New York because Pittsburgh is hard-working people. Everyone is down to earth. There’s no fakeness. And I think I grew up in the right way, and it made me tough enough to come to New York and conquer my dreams.”
Sharon Eberson: seberson@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1960. Twitter: @SEberson_pg. Sign up for the PG performing arts newsletter Behind the Curtain at Newsletter Preferences at post-gazette.com.